Collectors Don’t Just Pay for the Watch—They Pay for the Condition
In 2024, even rare references are falling flat at auction—if the condition isn’t there. Scratch-heavy cases, refinished dials, or polished lugs can crush resale value by 20–50%.
Auction expert Adam Levinsohn breaks down how top-tier buyers at Bond Street Auctions assess condition and how it directly impacts what you’ll get—or pay—on the block.
What “Top Condition” Actually Means
To maximize value, a watch should have:
• Unpolished case with sharp bevels
• Original dial (non-refinished, aged naturally)
• Strong bracelet integrity (no excessive stretch)
• Matching serials and movement numbers
• Minimal wear to bezel/crystal/lugs
“A rare model in bad shape is just a problem. A common model in perfect condition? That’s a prize,” says Levinsohn.
Auction Case Study: Condition vs. Value
Watch Condition Hammer Price
Rolex Sub 16610 (polished, replacement dial) Fair $9,800
Rolex Sub 16610 (unpolished, original papers) Excellent $14,400
47% higher price—same reference, different condition.
What Destroys Value Fast
1. Overpolishing – Removes factory bevels and softens edges
2. Service dials/hands – Reduces collector interest
3. Incorrect crown or pushers – Impacts both value and functionality
4. Re-lumed markers – Hard to spot, but always penalized
5. Bracelet swaps – Reduces historical accuracy
Levinsohn’s Pro Tip
“Ask for case thickness measurements and macro photos of lug bevels. Condition can’t be faked under 10x zoom.”
How Auction Houses Evaluate Condition
At Bond Street, every watch is condition-graded using:
• Macro photography (40x zoom)
• UV light for dial originality
• Bracelet stretch gauges
• Timegrapher reports
• Historical part comparison
Condition notes are listed in the catalog, so bidders know what they’re getting—no surprises.
FAQs
Can I polish my watch before selling?
No. Leave it as-is. Collectors prefer untouched—even with minor flaws.
What’s worse: a scratch or a refinished dial?
Refinished dial. Light scratches can be forgiven. Repainted dials destroy collector value.
Do auctions list every flaw?
Top houses like Bond Street do—right down to micro-nicks and bracelet slack.
Want Condition You Can Count On?
Browse authenticated, condition-verified Rolex, Patek, and AP at Bond Street Auctions.
👉 Explore listings at www.BondStreetAuctions.com
No comment yet, add your voice below!